Fig. 2. Heart lung machine developed at the University of Minnesota Fig. 4. Drs. Richard Varco and F. John Lewis standing with a cooling by Dr. C. Walton Lillehei and Dr. Richard DeWall. Photo courtesy of device used during open heart surgery. Photo courtesy of the Lillehei

Dr. Robert Gallegos.

Heart Institute.

Table 1

Anticoagulation After Prosthetic Heart Valves



Mechanical prosthesis

• First 3 months postimplantation

• After initial 3 months

• Aortic valve + risk factor

Biological prosthesis

• First 3 months postimplantation

• After initial 3 months

• Aortic valve + risk factor

Source: From ref. 7. INR, international normalized ratio.

Table 2

Tissue Valve Graft Options: Classification of Bioprosthetic Valves

Bioprosthetic valve


Stented porcine valve (xenograft) Stentless porcine valve (xenograft)

A three-leaflet valve supported by three artificial struts or stents to maintain leaflet structure and geometry

A length of porcine aorta including tissue below (proximal) and above (distal) to the valve, called the root

Bovine pericardial valve (xenograft) A three-leaflet valve created from bovine pericardium attached to a stented frame Homograft A human aortic valve and root

Autograft A pulmonary valve and root excised from and reimplanted in the same patient

(2) reduced thrombogenic (or clot forming) potential. Efforts to optimize valve hemodynamic function date back to the development of the Lillehei/Kaster tilting disk valve, which allowed blood to flow centrally through the valve. At that time, this new type of valve emphasized the requirement to design a valve that would reduce turbulent blood flow, reduce cell destruction, and minimize the transvalvular gradients (4). A transvalvular gradient is defined as the pressure difference across the valve. Despite the advantages of a new steel tilting disk design, careful and strict anticoagulation therapy was still required to reduce the risk of clot formation (5).

The next improvement of heart valves came with the development of the pyrolytic carbon valve leaflets. The nonthrom-bogenic properties, weight, and strength of pyrolytic carbon were described by Drs. Jack Bokros and Vincent Gott. Subsequently, pyrolytic carbon was used in the creation of a bileaflet valve, inspired by an idea of Dr. Kalke. This valve, manufactured by St. Jude Medical (St. Paul, MN), provides exceptional performance and remains today as the gold standard of valve designs (6).

Yet, since the first implantation, efforts to design the ideal mechanical heart valve prosthesis were affected by the challenges of thrombogenicity, turbulence, and hemolysis. Currently, all patients with mechanical valves still require anticoagulation therapy, typically with oral warfarin; the use of this agent has reduced the risk of thromboembolism to 1-2% per year (Table 1) (7). It should be noted that numerous studies have demonstrated that the risk of thromboembolism is related to the valve implant type, in the descending order of a tricuspid, mitral, and aortic implant. In addition, this risk of emboli appears to be greatest in the early postimplant time period and then reduces, as the valve sewing cuff becomes fully endo-thelialized.

In general, management of anticoagulation must be individualized to the patient, so to minimize risk of thromboembolism and at the same time prevent bleeding complications. When a patient with a valve prosthesis requires noncardiac surgery, warfarin therapy should be stopped only for procedures with a substantial risk of bleeding. A complete discussion of anticoagulation therapy is beyond the scope of this chapter; however, several excellent reviews are available on this subject (7).

2.2. Biological Prosthetic Valves

Because of the problems related to anticoagulation, much clinical research has focused on developing a tissue valve alternative that avoids the need for anticoagulation. From a historical perspective, Drs. Lower and Shumway performed the first pulmonary valve autotransplant in an animal model (8). In 1967, Dr. Donald Ross completed the first successful replacement of such in a human. The Ross procedure is a well-established method used today; to replace a diseased aortic valve with the patient's own pulmonary valve (Fig. 5). A donor tissue valve or homograft (Table 2) is then used as a prosthetic pulmonary valve.

Donald Ross Bunker Drawings
Fig. 5. Schematic drawing of the Ross procedure. (A) Resection of the diseased aortic valve. (B) Harvesting of native pulmonary valve. (C) Implantation of the pulmonic valve in the aortic position and reimplantation of coronary arteries.

In general, tissue valves are significantly more biocompatible than their mechanical counterparts. These valves are naturally less thrombogenic, and thus the patient does not require aggressive anticoagulation. Specifically, a risk of less than 0.7% per year for clinical thromboembolism has been reported in patients with valve replacement eliciting sinus rhythm without warfarin therapy (7). Therefore, this treatment option is advantageous in clinical situations when the use of anticoagulation would significantly increase the patient's morbidity and mortality. Yet, a potential major disadvantage of tissue valves is an early valvular degeneration as a result of leaflet calcification. Methods for tissue preservation to prevent calcification are currently a major focus of research in this field.

2.3. Biological vs Mechanical Valves

The choice of a mechanical or biological valve implant will depend on the patient's disease, the specific native valve involved, and the surgeon's preference and experience. If these factors are not limiting, the choice of valve type should be based on the maximization of benefits over risks for the individual patient. Mechanical valves offer greater durability, but at the cost of requiring lifelong anticoagulation. As such, mechanical valves are well suited for a younger patient who does not desire future reoperations.

Currently, mechanical valve replacement has been standardized and is commonplace, yielding satisfactory valve function that is quite reproducible from patient to patient. The flow gradients with newer bileaflet mechanical valves have dramatically improved from the early ball valve type; currently, a trileaflet valve is in the preclinical stages of development and may eventually not require anticoagulation therapy (see Fig. 2 in Chapter 21).

In the interim, bioprosthetic or tissue valves offer a safe alternative for patients in whom the risk of anticoagulation is prohibitively high (e.g., elderly patients older than 70 years of age, women of child-bearing years desiring pregnancy). Yet, the length of durability remains a serious concern for tissue valves, and thus a patient whose life expectancy is greater than that of the prosthesis will encounter the risk of another surgery for a second valve replacement.

Table 3

Reportable Valve Prosthesis Complications



Any change in function of an operated valve resulting from an intrinsic abnormality causing stenosis or regurgitation

Any stenosis or regurgitation of the operated valve that is not intrinsic to the valve itself, including inappropriate sizing but excluding thrombosis and infection

Any thrombus, in the absence of infection, attached to or near an operated valve that occludes part of the blood flow path or interferes with function of the valve

Any embolic event that occurs in the absence of infection after the immediate perioperative period (new temporary or permanent, focal or global neurological deficit and peripheral embolic event)

Any episode of major internal or external bleeding that causes death, hospitalization, or permanent injury or requires transfusion

Any infection involving an operated valve resulting in valve thrombosis, thrombotic embolus, bleeding event, or paravalvular leak

Source: From ref. 8.

Structural valvular deterioration Nonstructural dysfunction Valve thrombosis Embolism

Bleeding event

(anticoagulant hemorrhage)

Operated valvular endocarditis

Blood Vessel Valves Embolism
Essentials of Human Physiology

Essentials of Human Physiology

This ebook provides an introductory explanation of the workings of the human body, with an effort to draw connections between the body systems and explain their interdependencies. A framework for the book is homeostasis and how the body maintains balance within each system. This is intended as a first introduction to physiology for a college-level course.

Get My Free Ebook

Post a comment