Despite the unfamiliarity of most readers with diagnostic expert systems, we chose to begin our discussion of algorithms for biosurveillance with this topic because case detection provides the case data needed for outbreak detection. Outbreak detection cannot function without case detection (unless the surveillance data are aggregated data, such as daily sales of over-the-counter thermometers).
Diagnostic expert systems have the potential to improve the quality and completeness of the case data available to analytic methods designed to detect and characterize outbreaks, which we discuss in the following chapters. They can profoundly improve the reporting of syndromes. Improvements in case detection will translate directly into improvements in the ear-liness of outbreak detection and characterization.
McDonald did not conclude in his seminal paper that the solution to the non-perfectibility of man was to admit only women to medical schools. Rather, he stated, "Thus, I conclude that though the individual physician is not perfectible, the system of care is, and that the computer will play a major part in the perfection of future care systems." His point—that technology can be used to create a system (involving both humans and computers) that can then be perfected—also seems to apply to biosurveillance systems.
12. ADDITIONAL RESOURCES_
For readers who are interested in diagnostic expert systems for diagnosing plant diseases, Travis and Latin (1991) briefly reviewed several diagnostic expert systems in plant pathology, including PLANT/ed, Apple Pest and Disease Diagnosis, CALEX/Peaches, Muskmelon disorder management system, and Penn State Apple Orchard Consultant, in "Development, Implementation, and Adoption of Expert Systems in Plant Pathology."
This work was supported in part by grants from the National Science Foundation (IIS-0325581), the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (F30602-01-2-0550), and the Pennsylvania Department of Health (ME-01-737). We thank William Hogan and Gregory Cooper for helpful discussions and comments.
Adams, I. D., Chan, M., Clifford, P. C., et al. (1986). Computer aided diagnosis of acute abdominal pain: a multicentre study. BMJ (Clin Res Ed) 293:800-4. American College of Emergency Physicians. (1994). Clinical policy for the initial approach to patients presenting with a chief complaint of nontraumatic acute abdominal pain. American College of Emergency Physicians. Ann Emerg Med 23:906-22. Aronsky, D., Fiszman, M., Chapman, W. W., et al. (2001). Combining decision support methodologies to diagnose pneumonia. In: Proceedings of American Medical Informatics Association Annual Fall Symposium, 12-16. Boxwala, A. A., Peleg, M.,Tu, S., et al. (2004). GLIF3: a representation format for sharable computer-interpretable clinical practice guidelines. J Biomed Inform 37:147-61. Buchanan, B. G., Shortliffe, E. H. (1984). Rule-based expert systems: the MYCIN experiments of the Stanford Heuristic Programming Project. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley. Burnside, E. S., Rubin, D. L., Shachter, R. D., et al. (2004). A probabilistic expert system that provides automated mammographic-histologic correlation: initial experience. AJR Am J Roentgenol 182:481-8. Chung, S., Mandl, K. D., Shannon, M., et al. (2004). Efficacy of an educational web site for educating physicians about bioterrorism. Acad Emerg Med 11:143-8. Ciccarese, P., Caffi, E., Boiocchi, L., et al. (2004). A guideline management system. Medinfo 11:28-32. Cundick, R., et al. (1989). Iliad as a patient care simulator to teach medical problem solving. Paper presented at 13th Symposium on Computer Applications in Medical Care, Washington, DC.
de Clercq, P. A., Blom, J. A., Korsten, H. H., et al. (2004). Approaches for creating computer-interpretable guidelines that facilitate decision support. Artif Intell Med 31:1-27. de Dombal, F., de Baere, H., van Elk, P., et al. (1993). Objective medical decision making: acute abdominal pain. In: Beneken J, Thevenin V, eds. Advances in Biomedical Engineering: Results of the 4th EC Medical and Health Research Programme. Vol. 7 of Studies in Health Technology and Informatics, 65-87. Burke, VA: IOS Press. de Dombal, F., Leaper, D., Staniland, J., et al. (1972). Computer-aided diagnosis of acute abdominal pain. BMJ 2:9-13. de Dombal, F. T. (1975). Computer-aided diagnosis and decision-
making in the acute abdomen. J R Coll Physicians Lond 9:211-8. de Dombal, F. T. (1984). Computer-aided diagnosis of acute abdominal pain. The British experience. Rev Epidemiol Sante Publique 32:50-6. de Dombal, F. T. (1990). Computer-aided decision support in acute abdominal pain, with special reference to the EC concerted action. Int J Biomed Comput 26:183-8. de Dombal, F. T., Leaper, D. J., Horrocks, J. C., et al. (1974). Human and computer-aided diagnosis of abdominal pain: further report with emphasis on performance of clinicians. BMJ 1:376-80. Dexter, P. R., Perkins, S., Overhage, J. M., et al. (2001). A computerized reminder system to increase the use of preventive care for hospitalized patients. N Engl J Med 345:965-70. Elstein, A. S., Friedman, C. P.,Wolf, F. M., et al. (1996). Effects of a decision support system on the diagnostic accuracy of users: a preliminary report. J Am Med Inform Assoc 3:422-8. Espino, J., Dara, J., Dowling, J., et al. (2005). SyCo2: A Bayesian
Machine Learning Method for Extracting Symptoms from Chief Complaints And Combining Them Using Probabilistic Case Definitions. Pittsburgh, PA: Center for Biomedical Informatics, University of Pittsburgh. Espino J.,Tsui,F.-C. (2000). A Bayesian network for detecting inhalational anthrax outbreaks. Pittsburgh, PA: Center for Biomedical Informatics, University of Pittsburgh. Evans, R. S. (1991). The HELP system: a review of clinical applications in infectious diseases and antibiotic use. MD Computing 8:282-8, 315.
Feigenbaum, E. A. (1977). The Art of Artificial Intelligence: Themes and Case Studies of Knowledge Engineering. Paper presented at 5th International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence. Fox, J., Johns, N., Lyons, C., et al. (1997). PROforma: a general technology for clinical decision support systems. Comput Methods Programs Biomed 54:59-67. Friedman, C. P., Elstein, A. S.,Wolf, F. M., et al. (1999). Enhancement of clinicians' diagnostic reasoning by computer-based consultation: a multisite study of 2 systems. JAMA 282:1851-6. Gardner, R. M., Pryor,T.A.,Warner, H. R. (1999).The HELP hospital information system: update 1998. Int J Med Inform 54:169-82. Gerberding, J. L., Hughes, J. M., Koplan, J. P. (2002). Bioterrorism preparedness and response: clinicians and public health agencies as essential partners. JAMA 287:898-900.
Graber, M. A.,VanScoy, D. (2003). How well does decision support software perform in the emergency department? Emerg Med J 20:426-8.
Haynes, R. B., Davis, D.A., McKibbon, A., et al. P. (1984). A critical appraisal of the efficacy of continuing medical education. JAMA 251:61-4.
Heckerman, D. E., Horvitz, E. J., Nathwani, B. N. (1992).Toward normative expert systems. Part I. The Pathfinder project. Methods Inform Med 31:90-105.
Hripcsak, G., Knirsch, C., Jain, N., et al., (1999). A health Information network for managing innercity tuberculosis: bridging clinical care, public health, and home care. Computers Biomed Res 32:67-76.
Hripcsak, G., Knirsch, C. A., Jain, N. L., et al. (1997). Automated tuberculosis detection. J Am Med Inform Assoc 4:376-81.
Hughes, J. M., Gerberding, J. L. (2002). Anthrax bioterrorism: lessons learned and future directions. Emerg Infect Dis 8:1013-4.
Johnson, P.,Tu S., Jones, N. (2001). Achieving reuse of computable guideline systems. Medinfo 10:99-103.
Kahn, M. G., Bailey,T. C., Steib, S. A., et al. (1996a). Statistical process control methods for expert system performance monitoring. J Am Med Inform Assoc 3:258-69.
Kahn, M. G., Steib, S. A., Dunagan, W. C., et al. (1996b). Monitoring expert system performance using continuous user feedback. J Am Med Inform Assoc 3:216-23.
Kahn, M. G., Steib, S. A., Fraser, V. J., et al. (1993). An expert system for culture-based infection control surveillance. In: Proceedings of Annual Symposium on Computer Applications in Medical Care, 171-5.
Kohn, L. T., Corrigan, J., Donaldson, M. S., et al. (2000). To Err Is Human: Building a Safer Health System. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
Kolata, G. (2001). Florida Man Is Hospitalized with Pulmonary Anthrax. New York Times, October 5.
Leavitt, M. (2001). Medscape's response to the Institute of Medicine Report: crossing the quality chasm: a new health system for the 21st century. Med Gen Med 3:2.
Ledley, R. S., Lusted, L. B. (1959). Reasoning foundation of medical diagnosis: symbolic logic, probability, and value theory aid our understanding of how physicians reason. Science 130:9-12.
Leist, J. C., Kristofco, R. E. (1990). The changing paradigm for continuing medical education: impact of information on the teachable moment. Bull Med Libr Assoc 78:173-9.
London, S. (1998). DXplain: a web-based diagnostic decision support system for medical students. Med Ref Serv Q 17:17-28.
McAdam, W.A., Brock, B. M., Armitage,T., et al. (1990).Twelve years' experience of computer-aided diagnosis in a district general hospital. Ann R Coll Surg Engl 72:140-6.
McDonald, C. (1976a). Use of a computer to detect and respond to clinical events: its effect on clinician behavior. Ann Intern Med 84:162-7.
McDonald, C., Tierney, W., Overhage, J. (1991). H.I.S. and the physician: direct inpatient order entry by physicians through medical gopher workstations—problems and promises. In: Proceedings IMIA Working Conference on Trends in Modern Hospital Informatics .Systems, Gottingen, Germany, 71-80.
McDonald, C.,Tierney, W., Overhage, J., et al. (1992a). The
Regenstrief Medical Record System: 20 years of experience in hospitals, clinics, and neighborhood health centers. MD Computing 9:206-17.
McDonald, C. J. (1976b). Protocol-based computer reminders, the quality of care and the non-perfectability of man. N Engl J Med 295:1351-5.
McDonald, C. J. (1976c). Use of a computer to detect and respond to clinical events: Its effect on clinician behavior. Ann Intern Med 84:162-7.
McDonald, C. J. (1983). Computer technology and continuing medical education: a scenario for the future. Conn Med 47:159-62.
McDonald, C. J., Hui, S. L.,Tierney,W. M. (1992b). Effects of computer reminders for influenza vaccination on morbidity during influenza epidemics. MD Computing 9:304-12.
Miller, P. L., Frawley, S. J., Sayward, F. G., et al. (1997). Combining tabular, rule-based, and procedural knowledge in computer-based guidelines for childhood immunization. Comput Biomed Res 30(3):211-31.
Miller, R., Masarie, F. E., Myers, J. D. (1986). Quick medical reference (QMR) for diagnostic assistance. MD Computing 3:34-48.
Murphy, G. C., Friedman, C. P., Elstein, A. S., et al. (1996). The influence of a decision support system on the differential diagnosis of medical practitioners at three levels of training. In: Proceedings of American Medical Informatics Association Annual Fall Symposium, 219-23.
National Aeronautics and Space Administration A. C language integrated production system (CLIPS). http://www.www.ghg.net/ clips/WhatIs CLIPS. html.
Neapolitan, R. (2003). Learning Bayesian Networks. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Prentice Hall.
Overhage, J. M.,Tierney,W. M., McDonald, C. J. (1996). Computer reminders to implement preventive care guidelines for hospitalized patients. Arch Intern Med 156:1551-6.
Parker, C. G., Rocha, R. A., Campbell, J. R., et al. (2004). Detailed clinical models for sharable, executable guidelines. Medinfo 11:145-8.
Peleg, M.,Tu, S., Bury, J., et al. (2003). Comparing computer-interpretable guideline models: a case-study approach. J Am Med Inform Assoc 10:52-68.
Pynsent, P. B., Fairbank, J. C. (1989). Computer interview system for patients with back pain. J Biomed Eng 11:25-9.
Rind, D. M., Davis, R., Safran, C. (1995). Designing studies of computer-based alerts and reminders. MD. Computing 12:122-6.
Rind, D. M., Safran, C., Russell, S. P., et al. (1993).The effect of computer-based reminders on the management of hospitalized patients with worsening renal function. In: Proceedings of the 15th Annual Symposium on Computer Applications in Medical Care, Washington, D.C., 28-32.
Seyfang, A., Miksch S., Marcos, M. (2002). Combining diagnosis and treatment using ASBRU. Int J Med Inform 68:49-57.
Shannon, M., Burstein, J., Mandl K, et al. (2002). Usage of a web-based decision support tool for bioterrorism detection. Am J Emerg Med 20:384-5.
Shephard, R., Cameron, A.,Toribio J., et al. (2005). Bovine syndromic surveillance system. http://www. www. ausvet. com. au/bosss/.
Shiffman, R. N., Michel, G., Essaihi A., et al. (2004). Bridging the guideline implementation gap: a systematic, document-centered approach to guideline implementation. J Am Med Inform Assoc 11:418-26.
Shwe, M. A., Middleton, B., Heckerman, D. E., et al. (1991). Probabilistic diagnosis using a reformulation of the INTERNIST-1/QMR knowledge base. I. The probabilistic model and inference algorithms. Methods Inform Med 30:241-55.
Sorenson D, et al. (1988). Generation and maintenance of ILIAD medical knowledge in a hypercard environment. In: Proceedings of 12th Symposium on Computer Applications in Medical Care, Washington, D.C.
Terenziani, P., Montani, S.,Torchio, M., et al. (2003). Temporal consistency checking in clinical guidelines acquisition and execution: the GLARE's approach. In: Proceedings of American Medical Informatics Association Annual Symposium, 659-63.
Tierney, W. M., Miller, M. E., Overhage, J. M., et al. (1993). Physician inpatient order writing on microcomputer workstations. Effects on resource utilization. JAMA 269:379-83.
Travis J., Latin, R. (1991). Development, implementation, and adoption of expert systems in plant pathology. Ann Rev Phytopathol 29:343-360.
Tu, S. W., Musen, M. A. (2001). Modeling data and knowledge in the EON guideline architecture. Medinfo 10:280-4.
Turner, S. (2001). Bayesian Networks & More.
Wagner, M. M., Pankaskie, M., Hogan,W., et al. (1997). Clinical Event Monitoring at the University of Pittsburgh. In: Proceedings of American Medical Informatics Association Annual Fall Symposium, 188-92.
Wald, J. S., Rind, D., Safran, C., et al. (1995). Patient entries in the electronic medical record: an interactive interview used in primary care. In: Proceedings of Annual Symposium on Computer Applications in Medical Care, 147-51.
Wang, D., Peleg, M., Bu, D., et al. (2003). GESDOR—a generic execution model for sharing of computer-interpretable clinical practice guidelines. In: American Medical Informatics Association Annual Symposium, 694-8.
Warner, H., Jr., Blue, S. R., Sorenson, D., et al. (1997). New computer-based tools for empiric antibiotic decision support. In: Proceedings of American Medical Informatics Association Annual Symposium, 238-42.
Warner, H. R., Jr. (1989). Iliad: moving medical decision-making into new frontiers. Methods Inform Med 28:370-2.
Warner, H. R., Jr. (1990). Iliad: diagnostic tools for general medicine. Interview by Bill W. Childs. Healthcare Inform 7:38.
Warner, H. R., Jr., Bouhaddou, O. (1994). Innovation review: Iliad— a medical diagnostic support program. Top Health Inform Manag 14:51-8.
Warner, H. R.,Toronto, A. F., Veasey, G. (1964). Experience with Bayes theorem for computer analysis of congenital heart disease. Ann N Y Acad Sci 115:558-67.
Warner, H. R.,Toronto, A. F., Veasey, G., et al. (1961). A mathematical approach to medical diagnosis: application to congenital heart disease. JAMA 177:177-83.
Weinstein, M. C. (1980). The value of information. In: Clinical Decision Analysis, 131-67. Philadelpha: Saunders.
Williamson, J. W.,German,P.S.,Weiss, R.,et al. (1989). Health science Information management and continuing education of physicians: a survey of U.S. primary care practitioners and their opinion leaders. Ann Intern Med 110:151-60. Wilson, D. H., Wilson, P. D., Walmsley, R. G., et al. (1977). Diagnosis of acute abdominal pain in the accident and emergency department. Br J Surg 64:250-4. Wilson, P. D., Horrocks, J. C., Lyndon, P. J., et al. (1975).
Simplified computer-aided diagnosis of acute abdominal pain. BMJ 2:73-5.
Yasnoff, W. A., Humphreys, B. L., Overhage, J. M., et al. (2004). A consensus action agenda for achieving the national health Information infrastructure. J Am Med Inform Assoc 11:332-8.
Was this article helpful?